Article by Lora Cecere from Supply Chain Shaman; published on January 31st 2013
This week, I am grounded due to weather. So, I am spending my time writing. Music is blaring, my toe is tapping, and I am hard at work on what I love. I enjoy writing research.
I am currently writing an article on supply chain excellence. The time off the road is allowing me to think more critically about the path that got us here, and about what drives supply chain excellence (or more importantly, what does not drive improvement).
For years, I have listened to consultants espouse buzzword bingo. You know the drill. Getting“all the way to bright” by “harvesting the low-hanging fruit.” Or twisting the arm of the COO to use an Enterprise Resource Planning system to build the “right house of best practice” to drive supply chain excellence. I am tired of buzzword bingo.
To better understand this journey that we have been on together, I have been analyzing a decade’s worth of supply chain financial ratio data for nine industry subsegments. (You would be very proud of the spreadsheet that I am analyzing.) I am poring over the results.
I am trying to find good news; but over and over again, I see the same trend. Progress is stalled. Consider the above table on healthcare. While companies have increased Revenue per Employee across the healthcare value chain, the Days of Inventory have increased for suppliers, and there is a shift in power to the healthcare provider. Operating Margin is shifting, but total costs are going up.
When I look at a value chain (a cluster of industries chained together to deliver products and services), I see that we are pushing costs backwards in the supply chain, but not decreasing the total costs of the system. I also see that we are not decreasing the total inventory levels in the network or accelerating time to value.
When I evaluate companies at an enterprise level, I see the that growth has flattened, inventories are growing and we are losing operating margin. As a result, I believe that companies are at a Supply Chain Plateau. Performance is stalled.
Consider the case of food manufacturing. Companies in this industry have increased SG&A Margin/Revenue by 1%, lost 1% in operating margin and have increased average inventories by 22% over the last decade. The only metric that we have improved through ten years of IT investments is the revenue/employee number. I believe that the only way to get past this plateau of results is through holistic systems thinking, enlightened leadership and holding ourselves accountable to balance sheet results. The company that has done this the best in this food peer group is General Mills.
As I share the work that we are doing at Supply Chain Insights LLC on financial ratios and peer group performance with company leadership teams, I am shocked that their supply chain teams are not aware of their year-over-year performance against their peer group.
We have mapped over fifty of these evaluations in our Supply Chain Insights Communityand each time, teams are surprised. (I encourage teams to ask us for a custom analysis. We will run this analysis for each company free of charge.) So, as I sit here and finalize my reports for next week on supply chain excellence, I am thinking hard about all of the sage advice that companies have gotten from consultants. I am questioning how we got it all so wrong. Here I want to question some of it, because as a cook, I believe that sage is a best fit for turkeys, and I don’t believe I am surrounded by turkeys. I want my friends in supply chain management to accelerate performance. I want them to push themselves off of this supply chain plateau. Here are my thoughts:
Gotta run. Two reports to finish before Tuesday’s newsletter. Next week is the first anniversary of Supply Chain Insights. We are planning a big celebration. You will not want to miss it!
For those of you that have helped us in our first year journey, many thanks! We have had over 300 companies fill out our surveys, and more than 60 companies have welcomed us into their organizations to help them solve real-world supply chain problems. We are proud to have finished 15 research surveys, launched the Supply Chain Index, built the Supply Chain Insights Community, published a book and completed 24 reports. As you will see next week, we are just getting started. Much, much more in store for the upcoming year… But, more on that later.
With 20 billion dollar+ logistics companies amongst the 80+ speakers at the 3PL Summit and Chief Supply Chain Officer Forum, eft is pleased to release the timed agenda for the event.
Did you know contract logistics accounts for more than one third of the European logistics market by value? Which are the top five countries? How many people are employed in EU logistics? It’s all here…
Why would companies implement solutions that cost more, were longer to deploy, and had lower user satisfaction? Read Lora Cecere's thoughts on this.